The Incumbency Trap: Why Europe Is Struggling to Keep Pace in the Global Electrification Race

Published by The New York Times

The challenge of standing out in a crowded marketplace often requires looking past convention. Decades ago, early in his career working for a mirror manufacturer, entrepreneur Greg Jackson faced a classic business hurdle: a mirror has one fundamental job, which is to reflect. Category differentiation seemed nearly impossible when every product looked identical to the consumer. The simple yet transformative solution was to design mirrors with exceptionally wide frames for online listings. That distinct visual difference immediately caught buyers' attention and turned the business around.

Applying a different perspective remains central to modern innovation. According to Jackson, who later founded the major U.K. energy provider Octopus Energy, failing to see what lies outside regular operations stems from an “incumbency cost.” This hidden tax is embedded in the routine behavior of replicating yesterday's processes tomorrow, serving as one of the most significant brakes on growth and adaptability.

The Weight of Incumbency in Europe

While consumer demand for green technology remains high across Western markets, structural barriers often prevent legacy industries from moving at the necessary speed. Established players in sectors like automotive and energy frequently struggle to transition away from traditional models, hampered by rigid legacy systems and deep-rooted industry habits.

In contrast, regions unhindered by entrenched commercial interests are scaling new technologies at a remarkable pace. This dynamic is especially visible in the transportation sector, where massive commercial fleets and passenger vehicles are transitioning rapidly in parts of Asia. Battery-powered logistics trucks weighing nearly 50 tons, supported by rapid battery-swapping stations that cut charging times down to just a few minutes, demonstrate a level of large-scale deployment that legacy industrial economies are struggling to match.

Observers note that the scale of these overseas initiatives highlights a stark disparity in industrial velocity. As one observer remarked, "It is still minuscule compared to China. Europe lacks the scale to compete. What Europe needs is an Energy Union and Capital Market Union." Another commenter added: "The best electric trucks by far are made in Europe, by European manufacturers, with an ever increasing market share. We do not need to look to China to see what proper electrification of long-haul trucking is."

Navigating Supply Chains and Market Dynamics

Beyond vehicle manufacturing, the broader shift toward electrification relies heavily on securing raw materials and building robust supply chains. While domestic manufacturing capabilities exist within Western markets, environmental regulations, local opposition to resource extraction, and fragmented policies often complicate production.

Critics of current industrial policy argue that heavy reliance on external supply chains leaves domestic industries vulnerable. At the same time, others point out that technological leadership requires deliberate, long-term state planning rather than relying solely on market forces. As a participant in the ongoing debate observed, "Their results are consequences of policies not circumstances." Another commenter emphasized the structural advantages built over decades, noting that "they are controlling the lithium battery market not because they are the largest supplier of lithium but because they spent decades building the entire supply chain through deliberate policy decisions. Something, apparently we in Europe forgot how to do."

Embracing Creative Destruction

Economic theory suggests that true productivity growth largely stems from new market entrants rather than established giants guarding legacy revenue streams. When older industries maintain a stranglehold on policy and distribution channels, disruptive innovations are frequently delayed for decades.

Overcoming these structural hurdles requires fostering environments where new ideas can flourish without being crowded out by incumbent interests. Whether through streamlined regulatory frameworks, modernized infrastructure, or targeted investments in next-generation technology, the path forward depends on embracing agility and allowing older economic models to evolve alongside a rapidly changing global landscape.

The Incumbency Trap: Why Europe Is Struggling to Keep Pace in the Global Electrification Race
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles

About the publisher

The New York Times

The New York Times publishes independent journalism to help readers understand the world.

Read the full publisher profile